Monday, November 11, 2019

Beginning Moods

As Adam Kirsch's essay states, and you no doubt have realized, Moods is a fragmented book, in some ways as much like poetry as prose. Since you'll be reading poetry next semester in 102, I think it's good to develop some strategies about how to read complex texts. One good strategy in a text like this is to mark as you read specific sections that strike you as interesting, important, peculiar, puzzling, etc. and then return to those moments and try to make sense of them apart from the whole text. That way you learn to focus and be specific instead of making generalizations and vague statements unsupported by the text. Let's practice together:

45 begins:

      "Penina Tuchner we loved like the Twin Towers, especially when they were burning. If her bra were preserved in a museum, we'd go there and break the display-case glass.
      How she'd say 'Shalom,' ["peace" in Hebrew, used both in greeting and farewell] with that first syllable precisely placed between s and sh. Generally. She pronounced words like a swan sailing along on the Thames, next to the hotels..."

It's easy to see how 46 follows 45, esp. w/ this delightful statement:

     "We thought to ourselves then that they (which is to say, Mr. and Mrs. Tuchner) brought a baby girl into the world and waited until she grew up and now we take off all of her clothes."

However, how does 47 go w/ these two sections? A big part of reading Hoffmann seems to be the fluctuation between traditional transition and juxtaposition. Explore these three sections to see what the book is doing.

You might want to try this w/ some different sections in the reading. 


Also...

One question that I asked last week, which I feel we're only starting to explore, is the importance of the Holocaust to Hoffmann (we could just as well ask the importance of the Holocaust to all Jews). Neither Hoffmann nor his parents were put in a concentration camp, in fact, the reason they immigrated to Israel was to escape the Nazis. Still, the Holocaust seems to be a big part of Hoffmann's book, like it is for a lot of Jewish writers. Why do you think this is? How does he write about the Holocaust? (One good example is in section 49 where the narrator tries to see if the tattooed numbers on Mr. and Mrs. Hirsch's arms are in sequence. Jews were tattooed w/ numbers as they were being interred into the camps during WWII.)

Sunday, November 10, 2019

Primal vision

  For me, I think primal vision it from our imagine. What we think about, what we perspective about something it's all come from our imagine before we know about them. In this book it tells me "here is a persistent intuition that the world we see has a reality that this Babel of tongues can only obscure. ". We were born with our insights, we were learn everthing after we born. But the things come out from our mind that was our primal vision i think. 
  I didn't read a lot books before(specially English book). But i think Professor were share some good books for us. I were never read this kind of book, and i learn a lot things in it. Even though i need to do a lot research and translate, and it will take a long time. I agree with the correct order is different. It’s impossible to say what it is (if it were known, it would be thrown into disorder). It was like Parallel universe. This book is very abstract, but the author is lead you to tell there story and a chance to show it to the world.

primal visions

What I expect from Yoel Hoffmans Novel is to be kind of abstract asa a book. In the Essay it talks about how there is no real story to be found in the book, the book doesn’t have paragraphs that breaks them apart. What I’m overly expecting from the book is to be short and meaningful.That stories being so short also make a reader more invader as they are always intertwined and not losing interest in the same topic.
The Voice in writing that Krishna writes about would what the writer wants to tell a viewer/listener. Writing  creates visuals in your head much like when you look at a painting.when telling a story a writer would describe the visuals with words to compensate not actually being there in the story itself.A writer has the ability to tell there story and a chance to show it to the world.
Coherence is defined as being consistent, but In the context of Moods I believe its the way each short story flows into one another overall creating one combined story.Yoel uses coherence in His book by showing how he can write as story and visually it makes his story keen.
This essay is called primal visions since the book itself is not like no other . The visuals of this book makes you intrigued to read it , it also gives your a perspective of the idea the author is trying to portray
the quote “The More wonderful than the wonders people sit and talk about, is the fact that they sit and talk...” means to me personally is basic human interaction. Humans are social species and social interaction is needed for human survival if you look at to in a base level.The conversations you have with people can variety from small interactions to your deepest secrets but in the end you don’t feel alone. In a world where humans didnt interact with each other would cause a lot of stigma between people and humans feeling alone.

Saturday, November 9, 2019

Primal visions

       The essay is called primal visions because it is meant to be an intro into the book moods. You get a feel for what the book is about and for me it’s seems like a bunch of thoughts in one book. The book is not like a normal book with long rows of text but small paragraphs of his ideas and memories.  Yoel Hoffman talks about his childhood a bit explaining how his parents died when he was young to his love for a girl. It seams Yoel likes to write about love he explains about the girl he likes and talks about her body parts mostly her feet which He talks about touching them.

The word fragment is used by Yoel to break up memories which are bits and pieces of events in his life it adds to the books making his life more interesting. I think they way he uses his words and format  makes the book have a different feeling then if it was written like a normal book with linear format and less erratic thoughts.

Saturday, November 2, 2019

Malcolms trust in alex

When Malcolm told Alex that he trust him 70 percent it was a good thing because malcolm x doesn’t trust anyone 100 percent. In the beginning he told Alex he trust him 25 percent because they had a bad first start. I think malcolm can’t trust people 100 percent because of what happens to him his friend and leader of NOI who he trusted in was caught having affairs which hurt malcolm. This leads to malcolm having little trust in many people which this is a good thing for malcolm because he can’t be hurt like he was when he found out about the affairs he had it lead him to no trust NOI 100 percent. This Seoul’s lead him to be a target by them

Alex’s view on the Nation of Islam

Alex Hailey showed the Nation of Islam in a new light with his view on them being a cult more than a religious movement. We see through Malcolm x a member who supported the group till he saw there leader and close friend Elijah Mohammad break many of the rules of Islam with him having an Affair on his wife. After Malcolm trying to distance him self form NOI they tried to kill him by shooting at Him and trying to blow up his home and they were successful in killing him. This backs Alex’s point that the NOI changed from Malcolm wanted to t be to a violet group and as a reader you can see that it’s not all about the fallowing of Islam. Alex also said that Islam is like Christians they were formed and had a fallowing which grew and this would be the definition of a cult.

Primal Visions

Now that you've read this essay, what would you expect Yoel Hoffman's novel, Moods, to be like? (If you've started it already, how does the book align w/ what you've read here?) Adam Kirsch writes that "Voice and imagery do much more than narrative to make his work cohere, to the extent that he is interested in coherence..." Remember: the theme of this 101 class is "voice." What is voice in writing? What is coherence? Choose one of Kirsch's quotes of the six Hoffmann novels under discussion here and write about what you think the quote is doing. Other questions that I have:
  • Why is this essay called "Primal Visions"?
  • To me, one quote that Kirsch offers captures Hoffmann's philosophy, aesthetics, and style/voice (from the novel Bernhard): "More wonderful than the wonders people sit and talk about, is the fact that they sit and talk..." What does this quote mean to you?
  • What significance does the Holocaust seem to have for Hoffman's writing? 
  • The word fragment is used five times in the essay. What is a fragment and what do you think it has to do w/ Hoffmann's writing?
  • Kirsch compares Hoffmann to the modern paintings of the Russian-Jewish artist, Marc Chagall (b. 1887, d. 1985). The following are some paintings by Chagall. What qualities do you notice about these artworks? 
To Russia, Asses and Others, 1911


Calvary (Golgotha), 1912

The Drunkard, 1912
As we start this new book, what question(s) do you have?